While I've discussed randomness before, I've been thinking about it a little more now that I just had my first peek at the influence actions from Toulouse. It seems that, by and large, the number of options in the rules currently provides some measure of uncertainty. There were many watch or follow actions which didn't turn up a lot of results because people watched for the wrong thing or didn't put 2 levels into the actions so a single level of stealth was able to conceal things.
Some other rules for these types of games ditch the watch-follow-trace line and just have one generic watch, and if you beat the stealth by 2 whole points, you learn who was behind the action. I like the simplicity there, but it makes massive watch actions hella powerful: you'd basically know everything happening in the influence at the cost of not having much ability to do anything that turn. There's something I still like about the watch-follow-trace sort of stuff because as soon as you reveal one plan to your "allies" they might have enough information to watch for your action and trace it back to you, but also that you need to guess what your opponents' reactions will be.
When it comes to Attack, however, I feel like a little more randomness might be warranted. As it stands, in order to attack a level 3 influence, you need 4 levels in the attack. If that level 3 influence also has a level of defense, then you need 5 levels to successfully attack it. If a background like Domain Security might give a free bit of defence, attacks become very difficulty. And to attack that level 5 influence..? It could be virtually impossible. Obviously augments from disciplines, backgrounds, and abilities add a bit of randomness to the system, but this is clearly a little clunky.
Some other rules for these types of games ditch the watch-follow-trace line and just have one generic watch, and if you beat the stealth by 2 whole points, you learn who was behind the action. I like the simplicity there, but it makes massive watch actions hella powerful: you'd basically know everything happening in the influence at the cost of not having much ability to do anything that turn. There's something I still like about the watch-follow-trace sort of stuff because as soon as you reveal one plan to your "allies" they might have enough information to watch for your action and trace it back to you, but also that you need to guess what your opponents' reactions will be.
When it comes to Attack, however, I feel like a little more randomness might be warranted. As it stands, in order to attack a level 3 influence, you need 4 levels in the attack. If that level 3 influence also has a level of defense, then you need 5 levels to successfully attack it. If a background like Domain Security might give a free bit of defence, attacks become very difficulty. And to attack that level 5 influence..? It could be virtually impossible. Obviously augments from disciplines, backgrounds, and abilities add a bit of randomness to the system, but this is clearly a little clunky.