Showing posts with label Toulouse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toulouse. Show all posts

Monday, May 26, 2014

Keeping players interested

One issue with games in general, and probably online games like this in particular, is player retention. I haven't done a lot of thinking about this yet, other than trying to keep in mind that it can be a bit of an issue. If anyone has feedback on what helped them keep some interest or what was less motivating, let me know.

I hope, however, that a few things might help:

First off, being clear on what the game is about and why it is fun. I found this video about explaining game rules in the past couple months, and it was kind of eye-opening. Not just because I've been playing a bunch of board games and we almost always seem to have one new player, but because it's applicable to at least this sort of game in particular.

Second, but related to the first, we can be clear about what the commitment is. I found that about 1-2 hours a week was correct for me, but I'm not sure if that was everyone's experience. If you had 9 levels of influence, that might have been easier to deal with than 21 levels though. But not just a weekly commitment, but also the game's duration. I'm currently thinking of having a set end-time after about 4-5 months. It'll give players an idea of how much time they have to plan, but also bring the story to at least an interim ending. Then we can decide if we want to start a new chapter of the same game, take another do-over with the same sort of rules in a different setting, do a different style of game completely, or call it a fun time and be done with this sort of game for the time being. This also ties into that "why it's fun" bit because you can feel good about sticking through with it till the end if you have an idea of when the end will be.

Third, and still related to that video, is being clear about the rules. I like having them all in one pdf because I don't have internet access all the time, but some people might prefer things in a few shorter chunks that a wiki might provide. But we can look at how the rules are laid out and what we can do to help people understand their options. I think a quick three-minute youtube video showing a sample turn or how some influences might interact would do wonders, but also something like a one-page rules/turn summary so you could at least see all/most of your options at a glance. I already mentioned renaming some of the actions (Attack an opponent's influence, Conceal your Resources, etc.) so they're a bit more descriptive, which could help as well. In terms of a pdf of the rules, it could be linked a bit more, and page-breaks might make the document a lot longer, but dividing things into logical sections and making them a bit more digestible could also help here.

Fourth, we know that Toulouse had a bit of a slow start which may have put off some some people, not to mention the needs of real life, travel, etc. which might have interrupted things. For that, all we can do is try to make sure that people have some clearer goals and info on other characters from the beginning and try to accommodate to different schedules and timezones and so on. On the faction front, I'm hoping to get characters organized into factions, and also that clans will all actually have known relations (even if those relations aren't all sire and childe.).

Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Influence Actions in Toulouse

Just for your reference: Here's the breakdown of actions for turns 4 till the end for the PCs. The first few turns aren't in the website and I imagine they'd give Watch and Trace an even bigger piece of the pie.

Interesting to note that Boost had only two uses and Combine didn't make the list at all. Story actions came in nicely as the largest piece of the pie, though if you add all the information-gathering actions together they become the largest, overpowering attempts to hide anyone's actions. We did very little attacking one another, but note I did exclude the NPCs.

Randomness vs Certainty and failed actions

While I've discussed randomness before, I've been thinking about it a little more now that I just had my first peek at the influence actions from Toulouse. It seems that, by and large, the number of options in the rules currently provides some measure of uncertainty. There were many watch or follow actions which didn't turn up a lot of results because people watched for the wrong thing or didn't put 2 levels into the actions so a single level of stealth was able to conceal things.

Some other rules for these types of games ditch the watch-follow-trace line and just have one generic watch, and if you beat the stealth by 2 whole points, you learn who was behind the action. I like the simplicity there, but it makes massive watch actions hella powerful: you'd basically know everything happening in the influence at the cost of not having much ability to do anything that turn. There's something I still like about the watch-follow-trace sort of stuff because as soon as you reveal one plan to your "allies" they might have enough information to watch for your action and trace it back to you, but also that you need to guess what your opponents' reactions will be.

When it comes to Attack, however, I feel like a little more randomness might be warranted. As it stands, in order to attack a level 3 influence, you need 4 levels in the attack. If that level 3 influence also has a level of defense, then you need 5 levels to successfully attack it. If a background like Domain Security might give a free bit of defence, attacks become very difficulty. And to attack that level 5 influence..? It could be virtually impossible. Obviously augments from disciplines, backgrounds, and abilities add a bit of randomness to the system, but this is clearly a little clunky.

Friday, May 16, 2014

Reflections

One of the things I've learned in grad school is just how powerful reflection and revision can be. I used to fire essays off into the dropbox and forget all about them. I used to write long-winded emails and just click send. But things are legitimately better when you have time to look back with a critical eye. Sometimes you can go back and redo it, sometimes you can just hope to learn from your mistakes and by talking it through with friends. That said, Zack did some reflecting on where he went a little wrong with Toulouse, and I hope to use all this to improve Alexandria. Thank you.

Feedback on the Rules: From Toulouse to Alexandria

This is a copy of the summarized feedback we got on our Toulouse By Night online influence game, along with my brief responses to some of it.

===

Feedback and Update
FYI, we’re thinking of running a second game, but it’ll probably take 4-6 weeks before we could start.  We’re exploring a more powerful website to handle the computation behind the game, and allow for more players. We’re thinking of Alexandria in Late Antiquity as the setting, around 360. Constantine has recently legalized Christianity, but Pagans are still quite a powerful force in the Empire. Alexandria is a Greek city in Egypt, so it is a confluence of ancient philosophy, mysticism, and secrets from the past. It may not be the most familiar setting for everyone, but we’re not expecting much background info. We’ll try to recommend a couple vital Wikipedia pages, or some films for inspiration.